NEWSLETTER

Sign up to read weekly email newsletter

Science, Space & Technology

Hindupedia
Donate
Search
  • World
  • Business
  • Finance
  • Politics
  • Pages
    • Contact US
    • Search Page
    • 404 Page
Reading: Muslim Woman Challenges Sharia Inheritance Law, Supreme Court Seeks Government’s Response
Share
HindupediaHindupedia
  • Read History
  • Latest News
  • Finance
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Technology
  • Sports
Search
  • Pages
    • About us
    • Contact Us
    • Editorial Standards
    • Diversity and Inclusion Policy
    • Ownership and Funding Information
    • Privacy Policy
  • Personalized
    • Read History
  • Categories
    • Business
    • Politics
    • Technology
    • Environment
    • Finance
Follow US
Made by ThemeRuby using the Foxiz theme. Powered by WordPress

Home » News » Muslim Woman Challenges Sharia Inheritance Law, Supreme Court Seeks Government’s Response

News

Muslim Woman Challenges Sharia Inheritance Law, Supreme Court Seeks Government’s Response

By Shashikant Nirala
Last updated: January 30, 2025
6 Min Read
Share

A woman from Kerala has approached the Supreme Court, seeking exemption from Muslim personal law in matters of inheritance. Safiya, the petitioner, argues that though she was born into a Muslim family, but does not follow Islam and that’s why she is not be bound by Sharia law. the petitioner wants the Indian Succession Act, 1925, to apply to her inheritance rights instead.

The Supreme Court, acknowledging the complexity of the issue, has issued a notice to the central government, asking for its stand. A bench led by Chief Justice Sanjiv Khanna, along with Justices Sanjay Kumar and K.V. Viswanathan, is hearing the case.

I no longer have faith in Islam, so Muslim Personal Law should not apply to me

Safiya, from State of Kerala, who identifies as a non-believer, has not formally renounced Islam but does not follow its teachings. Under Islamic inheritance law, she is entitled to only one-third of her father’s property, while the remaining two-thirds would go to male heirs. She wants her father to have the legal right to leave her his entire estate, which is not allowed under Sharia law.

Her petition raises a crucial legal question: Should those who no longer believe in Islam still be subjected to its personal laws? Safiya argues that Article 25 of the Constitution, which guarantees religious freedom, should also include the right to not follow any religion. She insists that her fundamental rights are being violated by being forced to adhere to a faith-based legal system she does not recognize.

Supreme Court’s Response and Legal Implications

During the hearing, Chief Justice Khanna pointed out that this issue isn’t just about one religion. If ex-Muslims are allowed to opt out of Sharia law, similar provisions may be needed for people from other faiths who leave their religion. He also noted that in Hindu inheritance law, a person who converts out of Hinduism may lose certain succession rights.

The court has given the central government four weeks to submit its response. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, representing the Centre, acknowledged that the case raises important legal questions and sought time to file a detailed reply.

Women’s Rights in Islamic Inheritance

The case highlights a long-standing debate about gender disparity in Muslim inheritance laws. Under Sharia law, male heirs receive twice the share of female heirs. Many Muslim women have spoken out against this system, arguing that it limits their financial security and independence.

Safiya’s petition isn’t just about her personal rights—it could impact other Muslim women who want equal inheritance rights under India’s secular laws. If the Supreme Court rules in her favor, it may open the door for more women to challenge religious inheritance laws and seek protection under the Indian Succession Act.

What the Law Says

The Indian Succession Act, 1925, provides equal inheritance rights regardless of gender or religion, but it explicitly excludes Muslims under Section 58. This means that even if a Muslim does not practice Islam, they are still governed by Sharia law in matters of inheritance.

Safiya’s lawyer, Prashant Padmanabhan, has challenged the constitutionality of this exclusion, arguing that it forces individuals to follow religious laws against their will.

Personal Laws vs. Constitutional Rights

This case isn’t the first time India’s courts have debated the role of personal laws in a secular democracy. The Shayara Bano case (2017), which led to the abolition of triple talaq, was a landmark judgment where the Supreme Court ruled that personal laws cannot override fundamental rights.

Now, a similar question is being asked in the context of inheritance: Can a person be legally forced to follow religious laws if they no longer identify with that religion? The Supreme Court’s ruling in Safiya’s case could set an important precedent.

Centre submits reports to the supreme court

The case will be heard again in May 2025, after the Centre submits its response. The government’s position will be crucial in determining whether legal reforms are needed to address the concerns of individuals who leave their religion.

If the court rules in Safiya’s favor, it could challenge the long-standing dominance of religious laws over personal rights, potentially leading to a shift toward a uniform legal framework for inheritance.

For now, the case remains a focal point in the broader debate over personal laws, religious freedom, and gender justice in India. The final verdict could have implications not just for ex-Muslims, but for anyone seeking equal legal rights outside of religious frameworks.

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Be keep up! Get the latest breaking news delivered straight to your inbox.
[mc4wp_form]
By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Share This Article
Facebook Email Copy Link Print
Leave a Comment Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!
[mc4wp_form]

HOT NEWS

Modi and trump

Indian and U.S. diplomats are trying to arrange a meeting of Modi and Trump, But Why?

Politics
January 22, 2025
Rising Suicides Among Married Men Over Marriage-Related Issues – What Reports Reveal

Rising Suicides Among Married Men Over Marriage-Related Issues – What Reports Reveal

December 9, 2024, was a day like any other. People were sharing memes, chatting with…

March 18, 2025
India won the icc champions trophy final 2025

India Lifts Champions Trophy with 5 Wicket Win, Rohit Shines with 76

A Sunday night in Dubai, the stadium packed, and the air buzzing with excitement. India…

March 18, 2025
104-year-old life convict from UP released after 43 years in jail

104-year-old life convict from Uttarpradesh released after 43 years in jail

Today marks a day in history that records an incident, one that not only raises…

May 30, 2025

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

UK’s NCA Issues First Interpol Silver Notice to Trace Indian-Origin Fraudster Anoop Maudhoo’s Assets

The UK’s National Crime Agency (NCA) has issued its first Interpol Silver Notice to track and recover the criminal assets…

News
April 15, 2025

‘Mom, I Didn’t Steal the Chips…’ 13-Year-Old Boy Wrote in His Suicide Note After Being Accused of Stealing Chips Packet

A heart-wrenching incident in Panskura, East Midnapore district of West Bengal, has left the entire country in shock. A 13-year-old…

News
May 24, 2025

Tax Officers Get Keys to Your Messaging App: New Income Tax Bill Stirs Privacy Storm

We are waking up to a world where your private WhatsApp chats, those late-night rants with friends, or even your…

News
March 5, 2025

Delhi High Court Shakes Up the Mobile Phone Debate: Total Ban in Schools Deemed Unworkable

Delhi HC rules total ban on students’ phones in schools unworkable, sets guidelines for regulated use—safety and education win over…

News
March 3, 2025
We use our own and third-party cookies to improve our services, personalise your advertising and remember your preferences.

Follow US: 

Foxiz Quantum US

The Business Centre 132, My Street Kingston, New York 12401 United States
Tel: +1-541-234-3010

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?